C_R

4084 Reputation

21 Badges

7 years, 63 days

MaplePrimes Activity


These are replies submitted by C_R

@nm 

This will also be quite usefull elsewhere. However, I have to get better at type selection for subsindets. Thanks!

@acer 

This must be a language problem on my side. I have tried to resolve the contradiction by rewriting the original post. I have also removed the questions about absorbing a factor under a root but left a link to the original document. Absorbtion is inverse to the extraction of a factor from a radical which was sufficiently discussed in the former post.

@acer 
The only reason why I desire from time to time to rearrange Maple output is to make it easier understandable or to better match math formating conventions/habits. It's for communication not for doing math. Such output can be considered final. 

In this particular case, factoring/collecting (1+x) is something what most people would do by hand or other CAS do. An outsider would probably judge from Maple's output that the math engine is not as sophisticated as other engines. 

Other examples of Maple output that I like to change are the leading minus sign when Maple applies automatic sorting or the sqrt(2)/2 factor instead of dividing by sqrt(2).

With Maple clean document are possible. Maplesoft can be proud of it. To make a document even better a final touchup is desirable (from time to time). Hence Q1. (Q2 and Q3 are more to see whehere are better techniques).

Comming back to Q1. If there are no better ways collecting (x+1), that are ideally self-explaining, I would do the following

a = 1 + x;
isolate(%, x);
subs(%, %%, expr);

Are there really no other ways?

@nm 

I have submitted a software change request. Maple does not seem to recognise in this case that numerator and denominator contain polynoms with same primitive parts (but of different powers). Primitive parts, if I understand correctly, are fundamental in algebra and can be used to normailize expression. This probably also explains why evala sometimes is helpfull at simplifing expressions. 

Only if combine is used with my original assumptions, sqrt(2) is extracted and a subsequent simplify is effective with assumptions on beta. Intuetively I would not have expected that combine can extract sqrt(2).

I stopped trials with your assumption -1 < x which indicates that the result is valid for a larger domain. How to get there with Maple?

Output[61] without using a combine command is of course reason enough that Maplesoft has close look.

221298  
228066 

@acer @dharr

Thank you

Maybe an alternative:

In the view tab on the ribbon is an option where mouse scrolling worked on my Windows 11 installation. 

Using it involves quite some clicks and mouse movements...

The problem is that is can get "polutet" with Help Pages.

@acer 

Too bad that your utilities have dissapeared. They might have adressed a niche topic but there will allways be users striving for simplicity (in code and results) beyond looking for pragmatic solutions.

(Dumb and boring) AI is not a help here and I do not see an (affordable) AI agend testing "all" combinations of Maple commands with brute force anytime soon. 

I keep it with Leonadro Da Vinci who supposedly said:

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.

@acer 

I am almost sure that I tried this but maybe I forgot to add the assumptions. 

It would be nice to have a routine that does the trial and error to find a solution. (Like int with the option 

method=_RETURNVERBOSE). I think @nm once showed here a routine that tried many "simplification" ways. 

Anyway, I am glad that I have asked. The command works for the elliptic integral to my full satisfaction.
Thank you.

PS.: I did not expect Maple 2026 to be any better. Is it?

@dharr 
Interesting and unexpected. I could not dedcuce this use from the help page of evala.
Thanks.

@acer 

Thank you

`&#128077`;

or

👍(not printing in text mode)

Good initiative. I am a bit worried that a new generation of engineers and managers trust AI too much.

I noticed in the ladder example provided on ExaktAI that units are not well handled (yet).

When ExaktAI (the underlying LLMs) can handle this, a list of 100 "typical" engineering problems would be interesting to benchmark.

A calcualtion annecdote came to my mind when reading your post: I learned from a retired optics specialist that, before the advent of computers, 3 independent human calculations where required before design and manufacturing of lens systems could start. Work was mentally so exhausting that the human caculators had a 6 hours working day... That was less than 70 years ago.

Does Maple "chokes" with the uploaded example or does it require special settings? What do you exactly mean by choking?

Example_Generate_Models-2025.2.mw

@wingho

I assume that with "literature" you mean the Maple help system.

I had a look at pdsolve documentation. I do not see a pdsolve option that reports of solver settings (including the type of solver). This would be useful when it comes to modifying default parameters and solvers.

I also tried infolevel[pdsolve] := 5, but this does not give more information (this works for dsolve).

Have you consulted: ?pdsolve,numeric,education/p>

This seems to offer more options (solvers and parameters) to solve your pde.

About the physical problem:

Can I assume that u(x,0) is equivalent to the compression of a rod at t=0?

If so, the solutions make quite sense to me. The relaxation propagates with the speed of sound. It reminds me of a falling slinky.

Remarks: The initial compression with 25% is quite high which could require modeling that accounts for large deflections (non-linear effects).

@dharr 

Compared to my original post, your puzzle can be reproduced. It is probably a regression.

Unfortuneately we cannot probe what the user interface sends to the kernel and what the kernel receives.

Edit: I seems that MaplePrimes has different challenges interpreting 2D-Math. Better open the attached worksheet

Pasted from
https://www.mapleprimes.com/questions/243578-Lprint-Not-Working#comment317499

a+b; %-op(2, %)

Error, invalid sum/difference

"a+b; %-op(2,`%`); "

 

Document block inserted an entered by hand

a+b; %-op(2, %)

a

(1)

Again pasting

> 

a; b; %-`%%`

Error, invalid sum/difference

"a;b; %-`%%`; "

 

entering by hand

a; b; %-`%%`

Error, invalid sum/difference

"a;b;  %-`%%`;"

 

a; b; %-`%%`

b-a

(2)

Pasting

> 

a; b; %-`%%`

Error, invalid sum/difference

"a;b; %-`%%`;  "

 

Deleting the line break

> 

a; b; %-`%%`

a

 

b

 

b-a

(3)

NULL

Inserting a line break with crtl+enter

> 

a; b; %-`%%`

Error, invalid sum/difference

"a;b;  %-`%%`;  "

 

NULL


 

Download ditto_2-D_Math.mw

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Last Page 7 of 84